When Daniel Christiansen boarded a recent Delta Air Lines flight from Salt Lake City to Palm Springs with his wife and infant daughter, he thought he’d hit the jackpot. “Delta is looking for one volunteer to give up their seat in exchange for $15,000,” an attendant announced. 

The flight attendant's offer wouldn't just upend his recent trip; it also would test his loyalty to the airline. Christiansen, a Gold Medallion-level flyer, didn’t hesitate. He rang the call button and confirmed the amount twice with the crew. Then he disembarked, leaving his family onboard. 

But, by the time the plane taxied away, Delta’s offer had shrunk to $1,500. Gate agents accused him of lying about the $15,000 promise. “They treated me like I’d invented the number out of thin air,” Christiansen says. “But the flight attendant, the captain, and even Delta’s own emails later admitted the $15,000 offer was real.”  

His case raises three critical questions for travelers:  

* Are airlines legally required to honor compensation promises made during flights?  

* What can you do if an airline refuses to keep its word? 

* How can passengers protect themselves from bait-and-switch tactics?  

Are airlines legally required to honor compensation promises made during flights? The short answer: It’s complicated.  

When a flight crew offers compensation verbally, it’s generally considered a unilateral contract – a promise in exchange for an action (in this case, surrendering a seat). If you fulfill your end, the airline should fulfill its end. But airlines aren’t banks. They’ll argue that "inadvertent" errors void the agreement, especially if the offer seems implausible.  

Delta admitted the $15,000 announcement happened but called it a "miscommunication." That’s corporate-speak for, "We messed up, but we won’t fix it." 

Verbal promises? Those hinge on state contract laws. Utah, where Christiansen took the deal, enforces oral contracts if there’s clear evidence of an offer, acceptance and "detrimental reliance" –like giving up a seat.  

But suing an airline over $15,000 isn’t practical for most travelers. And the airline industry's federal preemption means the airline could argue that state laws don't apply to this situation. Christiansen would spend more on legal fees than he'd recover. That’s why airlines gamble on you walking away.

What can you do if an airline refuses to keep its word?  

Start with the paper trail. Christiansen emailed Delta immediately, citing witnesses and demanding the $15,000. 

Is there a legal approach? Possibly. An appeal to the Utah Division of Consumer Protection might have prodded Delta into doing what it originally promised. A letter or email threatening to sue the airline, however, would have just been referred to Delta's legal department, where it would have languished until Christiansen filed an actual lawsuit.

There's also the social media route, better known as public shaming. Airlines hate bad publicity. A viral TikTok video or post on X could have nudged Delta to fix this problem. But it turns out Christiansen had one more card to play.

How can passengers protect themselves from bait-and-switch tactics?  

Christiansen’s mistake was trusting a verbal offer. Don't leave your seat until you know for certain that you're going to get what the airline promised you.

Always:  

* Get it in writing. If possible, ask for something in writing before you give up your seat and exit the plane. Don't leave the plane without it. 

* Record the offer. Utah allows one-party consent for audio recordings. A quick voice memo could’ve strengthened his case.  

* Know your rights. DOT rules cap cash compensation, but airlines can offer more in vouchers. Fifteen thousand dollars is rare but not illegal.  

I contacted Delta on Christiansen's behalf, hoping it would review his case one more time. True, a $15,000 offer to give up your seat is generous, but it's not unprecedented.

The response? "Our Care team shared that they’ve resolved this with the customer," a representative said.

I checked with Christiansen, who said Delta hadn't been in contact with him. So, I circled back to Delta and asked for details. "Our Customer Care team reached out to this customer and handled their submission. We've provided 20,000 SkyMiles as a tangible apology in conjunction with the $1,500 voucher," the Delta rep told me. ”This customer’s entry has been acknowledged, and they have been compensated. We thank the customer for trusting Delta for their travels.”

So that's it. No $15,000. No apology. Just $1,500 and a shrug. For Christiansen, this isn't about money but trust. As a loyal Delta customer, how can he trust Delta, knowing that it dangled a $15,000 carrot and then snatched it back?

And maybe that's the point. Maybe you can't trust an airline to do what it says. Always, always get a promise in writing.

Christopher Elliott is an author, consumer advocate and journalist. Reach him at [email protected].

Comments